• Skip to navigation
  • Skip to content
Davies Collison Cave Davies Collison Cave
Phone: 1800 636 588
  • Services
    Back Services Overview
    Service
    • Patents
      Back Patents Overview
      • Patent Drafting, Filing & Prosecution
      • Innovation Patents
      • Patent Searching
      • Patent Oppositions
      • IP Portfolio Management and Maintenance
      • Patent Litigation
      • Commercialisation and Licensing of Patents
      • New Zealand Patent Services
      • Patent Registration Services – South Pacific Region
      • Plant Breeder’s Rights
      • PCT Wheel English
      • PCT Wheel Chinese
    • Trade Marks
      Back Trade Marks Overview
      • Trade Mark Registration
      • Trade Mark Searching
      • Trade Mark Portfolio Management & Renewals
      • Domain Name Protection & Disputes
      • Business Name Protection
      • Plant Name Protection
      • Trade Mark Infringements & Enforcement
      • Trade Mark Commercialisation & Licensing
      • New Zealand Trade Mark Services
      • Pacific Island Trade Mark Protection
    • Designs & Copyright
      Back Designs & Copyright Overview
      • Design Registration
      • Design Infringements & Enforcement
      • Copyright Protection and Enforcement
    • Commercialisation
      Back Commercialisation Overview
      • Commercialisation and Licensing
      • Confidential Information
      • Competition Law and Consumer Protection Law
      • Privacy and Data Protection
    • Litigation & Dispute Resolution
      Back Litigation & Dispute Resolution Overview
      • IP Mediation
      • IP Litigation
      • Anti-counterfeiting
      • Parallel Imports
    • Overseas Applicants
      Back Overseas Applicants Overview
      • Overseas Applicants
      • Patent Filing Requirements in Australia and New Zealand
      • Trade Mark Filing Requirements in Australia and New Zealand
      • Design Filing Requirements in Australia and New Zealand
      • PCT Wheel English
      • PCT Wheel Chinese
    • Privacy and Data Protection
    • Technology, Media and Telecommunications
    Service Offerings
    • Patent Drafting, Filing & Prosecution
    • Innovation Patents
    • Patent Searching
    • Patent Oppositions
    • IP Portfolio Management and Maintenance
    • Patent Litigation
    • Commercialisation and Licensing of Patents
    • New Zealand Patent Services
    • Patent Registration Services – South Pacific Region
    • Plant Breeder’s Rights
    • PCT Wheel English
    • PCT Wheel Chinese
    • Trade Mark Registration
    • Trade Mark Searching
    • Trade Mark Portfolio Management & Renewals
    • Domain Name Protection & Disputes
    • Business Name Protection
    • Plant Name Protection
    • Trade Mark Infringements & Enforcement
    • Trade Mark Commercialisation & Licensing
    • New Zealand Trade Mark Services
    • Pacific Island Trade Mark Protection
    • Design Registration
    • Design Infringements & Enforcement
    • Copyright Protection and Enforcement
    • Commercialisation and Licensing
    • Confidential Information
    • Competition Law and Consumer Protection Law
    • Privacy and Data Protection
    • Technology, Media and Telecommunications
    • IP Mediation
    • IP Litigation
    • Anti-counterfeiting
    • Parallel Imports
    • Overseas Applicants
    • Patent Filing Requirements in Australia and New Zealand
    • Trade Mark Filing Requirements in Australia and New Zealand
    • Design Filing Requirements in Australia and New Zealand
    • PCT Wheel English
    • PCT Wheel Chinese
  • Industries & Technology
    Back Industries & Technology Overview
    • Agribusiness, Food and Nutrition
    • Arts, Marketing and Media
    • Biotechnology
    • Building and Construction
    • Chemical Engineering & Materials Science
    • Clean Technology and Energy
    • Electrical and Electronic Engineering
    • Engineering and Manufacturing
    • Fashion, Architecture and Design
    • Food, Beverages & FMCG
    • ICT & Software
    • Medical Devices & Technologies
    • Mining and Resources
    • Nanotechnology
    • Pharmaceuticals & Chemistry
    • Universities and Research
  • About DCC
    Back About DCC Overview
    • Our History
    • Awards
    • DCC News
  • Locations
    Back Locations Overview
    • Melbourne
    • Sydney
    • Brisbane
    • Singapore
    • Greater Western Sydney
    • Newcastle
    • Canberra
    • Geelong
    • Tasmania
    • Regional Australia
    • Adelaide
  • IP News
    Back IP News Overview
    • IP Articles
    • IP Update
    • IP Update Subscription
  • IP Info & Tools
    Back IP Info & Tools Overview
    • DCC Videos
    • Introduction to types of IP
    • Patent basics
    • Innovation Patents
    • Patenting process in Australia
    • Trade mark basics
    • Trade mark process in Australia
    • Trade mark process in NZ
    • Plant Name Protection
    • Copyright basics
    • Raising the bar guide
    • PCT Wheel English
    • TM Wheel
    • PCT Wheel Chinese
  • Our People
  • Careers
    Back Careers Overview
    • Current vacancies
    • General Career Enquiries
    • Trainee attorneys
    • IP law clerkship
    • Patent Internship Program
  • Contact
    Back
    Contact Us
    View all contacts
    • Phone Melbourne office +61 3 9254 2777
    • Fax Melbourne office +61 3 9254 2770
    • Phone Sydney office +61 2 9293 1000
    • Fax Sydney office +61 2 9262 1080
    • Phone Brisbane office +61 7 3011 9700
    • Fax Brisbane office +61 7 3011 9701
    • Phone Singapore office +65 6727 3777
    • Fax Singapore office +65 6727 3771
    • Phone Parramatta and Greater Western Sydney office +61 2 8896 6200
    • Fax Parramatta and Greater Western Sydney office +61 2 9262 1080
    • Phone Newcastle and The Hunter Region office +61 2 4960 8366
    • Fax Newcastle and The Hunter Region office +61 2 9262 1080
    • Phone Canberra office +61 2 6248 8063
    • Fax Canberra office +61 2 6248 6591
    • Phone Geelong office +61 3 5247 9334
    • Fax Geelong office +61 3 9254 2770
    • Phone Tasmania office 1800 636 588 (free call)
    • Phone Regional Australia office 1800 636 588 (free call)
    • Phone Adelaide office 08 7088 4878
    • Send an online enquiry
    Location
    • Melbourne
    • Sydney
    • Brisbane
    • Singapore
    • Greater Western Sydney
    • Newcastle
    • Canberra
    • Geelong
    • Tasmania
    • Regional Australia
    • Adelaide
  • Home
  • IP News
  • The Death of “Zombie” Marks

The Death of “Zombie” Marks

21 June, 2017 By Ian Drew and Nicholas Butera

This article first appeared in the INTA Bulletin dated 15 May 2017, Vol 72 No.9

A decision from the Australian Trade Marks Office in 1872 Holdings VOF v. Havana Club Holding SA [Feb. 21, 2017] ATMO 12 provides guidance on both the treatment of “zombie” marks and the binding nature of the Statement of Grounds and Particulars (SGP) in oppositions.

The Issues

In Australia, a zombie trademark is a mark which was pending or registered at the time a later application is filed, but is removed from the register before the outcome of the later application is determined. In theory, a zombie mark may still block a later conflicting application, as the mark was alive at the date on which the dispute is determined. Additionally, since the “Raising the Bar” reforms in April 2013, opponents have been required to file an SGP setting out the grounds and supporting particulars for the opposition. As the grounds of their particulars often become apparent once evidence has been lodged, there has been a degree of uncertainty as to whether an opponent is bound by the grounds as particularized.

The Opposition

The applicant, Havana Club Holding SA (Havana Club), sought extension of protection of its mark HAVANA CLUB ESSENCE OF CUBA to Australia with respect to a range of goods and services, including alcoholic beverages in Class 33.

The opponent, 1872 Holdings VOF (1872 Holdings), opposed registration on a number of grounds, including:

  •     S44 of Trade Marks Act — 1872 Holdings asserted that its earlier refused application for MATUSALEM EL ESPIRITU DE CUBA (the zombie mark) should prevent registration of the opposed mark. Although pending at the filing date of the opposed mark, it had been refused registration when opposed for containing a false geographical indication. Havana Club Holding SA and Corporacion Cuba Ron S.A. v. 1872 Holdings VOF [2016] ATMO 37.
  •     S42 of Trade Marks Act — 1872 Holdings asserted that use of the opposed mark would mislead or deceive in breach of the Australian Consumer Law in light of its earlier reputation in the marks THE SPIRIT OF CUBA LIBRE, EL ESPIRITU DE CUBA, and EL ESPIRITU DE CUBA LIBRE; however, at the hearing, 1872 Holdings also asserted that the mark would be misleading or deceptive if the relevant goods did not originate from Cuba, which was not particularized in its SGP.

Did the Zombie Mark Rise from the Dead?

The delegate of the Registrar of Trade Marks refused to reject the application based on the zombie mark. Even though the ground of opposition is determined by reference to the filing date of the application, the delegate noted that there was a number of provisions in the Act and accompanying regulations (particularly those in relation to deferments and amendments) which would be “rendered otiose” if circumstances arising after the filing date were considered irrelevant. The delegate observed that the “present tense” wording of Section 44, led the delegate to conclude that the Act should be “applied having regard to the status of potentially conflicting marks at the time of the assessment.”

Was 1872 Holdings Bound by the SGP?

The delegate gave this issue short and definitive shrift, stating:

[t]his was not a ground detailed in the Opponent’s Statement of Grounds and Particulars; nor was there an application from the Opponent to amend its Statement of Grounds and Particulars. Accordingly, that is the end of the matter.

The decision confirms the Trade Marks Office’s view on zombie marks and the need to adequately particularize grounds of opposition. Attorneys should ensure that earlier rights relied upon in opposition proceedings are maintained, and if circumstances enliven other grounds of opposition, their SGP should be amended immediately.

Filed Under: IP article IP Articles Trade Marks

Get in touch about this article

  • Ian Drew (Trade Marks Attorney)
    Ian Drew

    Principal | Trade Marks Attorney

    Contact Ian

  • Nicholas  Butera (Trade Marks Attorney)
    Nicholas Butera

    Associate | Trade Marks Attorney

    Contact Nicholas

Useful Tools

  • Download pdf
  • Email
  • Tweet
  • Share via linkedin

Share this on...

Twitter LinkedIn

You may also be interested in…

  • Clarification on Obligations of Confidentiality – Start-ups Take Note!

    18 April, 2018

    Rohm and Haas Electronic Materials CMP Holdings, Inc v NexPlanar Corp and another [2017] SGHC 310 This dispute revolves around a patent...

  • Intellectual Property Protection in Cambodia

    16 April, 2018

    Cambodia is a developing country supported mainly by three pillars of economic development - agriculture, tourism and textiles. With an...

  • Amendments Clarify New Zealand Patent Practice

    12 April, 2018

    Changes introduced with the Patents Amendment Regulations 2018 have clarified New Zealand patent practice   The New Zealand...

Return to
IP News
Questions?
Contact us

Get in touch about this article

  • Ian Drew (Trade Marks Attorney)
    Ian Drew

    Principal | Trade Marks Attorney

    Contact Ian

  • Nicholas  Butera (Trade Marks Attorney)
    Nicholas Butera

    Associate | Trade Marks Attorney

    Contact Nicholas

Useful Tools

  • Download pdf
  • Email
  • Tweet
  • Share via linkedin

Quick Links

  • Our People→
    • Patent attorneys Melbourne
    • Patent attorneys Sydney
    • Patent attorneys Brisbane
    • Trade mark attorneys Melbourne
    • Trade mark attorneys Sydney
    • Trade mark attorneys Brisbane
    • IP lawyers Melbourne
    • IP lawyers Sydney
    • IP lawyers Brisbane
  • Services→
    • Patents
    • Trade Marks
    • Designs & Copyright
    • Commercialisation
    • Litigation & Dispute Resolution
    • Overseas Applicants
  • IP News→
    • IP Articles
    • IP Update
    • IP Update Subscription
  • IP Info & Tools→
    • DCC Videos
    • Introduction to types of IP
    • Patent basics
    • Innovation Patents
    • Trade mark basics
    • Copyright basics
    • PCT Wheel
  • Key Locations→
    • Melbourne
    • Sydney
    • Brisbane
    • Singapore

Servicing Australia, New Zealand & Asia Pacific

  • Melbourne

    +61 3 9254 2777

  • Sydney

    +61 2 9293 1000

  • Brisbane

    +61 7 3011 9700

  • Singapore

    +65 6727 3777

  • Parramatta and Greater Western Sydney

    +61 2 8896 6200

  • Newcastle and The Hunter Region

    +61 2 4960 8366

  • Canberra

    +61 2 6248 8063

  • Geelong

    +61 3 5247 9334

  • Tasmania

    1800 636 588 (free call)

  • Regional Australia

    1800 636 588 (free call)

  • Adelaide

    +61 8 7088 4878

Website by August

© 2006-2018 Davies Collison Cave. Disclaimer & Privacy